BMW Forum - BimmerFest BMW Forums banner

Does the 335i step sometimes hold gears for "too long?"

2.8K views 9 replies 8 participants last post by  akula57  
#1 ·
Unfortunately my knee no longer allows me to drive a manual. But the BMW step is pretty good. In DS when I give it a lot of throttle and then hold speed the engine sometimes stays at 5,000 revs or so. I have to give it less throttle or switch to D to get the revs down or get it to shift.

Anyone else notice this? :angel:
 
#4 ·
Yes, I've noticed this from time to time, but not often, and only in DS. When it happens, I usually just tap the shift lever to a higher gear in manual mode, rather than shifting to D. I view it as a sign that I'm smarter than the transmission, and it is time to take over in manual mode for a while. ;)
 
#5 ·
It is intentional, trying to keep you in a gear rather than shift when you didn't want it to. This is the main reason I rarely use DS unless I am really hitting the twisties hard. It's not fault to DS, it's just designed to keep you in gears longer. The car is just as fast in drive at WOT.
 
#8 ·
It is doing what it is supposed to. It thinks you are on a track, or in some situation where you do not want an unexpected shift in the middle of a turn. If you want to out think it, out think it - use the paddles; that is what they are for.
+1. That delay gives you instant thrust should you get back on the gas at the corner exit. DS isn't really ideal for everyday slogging, you're better off leaving it in D unless you are driving aggressively or manually shifting.
 
#10 ·
Good points but I find D to be much less aggressive than

DS. Punching it when in DS pushes me back in the seat whereas D can seem a bit too laid back. Also, I'm not sure but doesn't D start in 2nd gear rather than 1st.

Oh, well, I guess DS and switching to D when it holds the revs too high.

I don't have paddle shifters and suspect I wouldn't use the manumatic. Still, it might be worth a shot. :angel: